top of page

Caribbean Custard and Italian Ice

Welcome to Caribbean Custard! Here, you can enjoy a delicious frozen custard or amazing gelato with an Italian ice or maybe a raspberry shake. They have the perfect dessert for everyone. One of the top-rated ice cream stops in Bear Lake, it’s definitely worth trying. Plus they usually have shorter lines!

Address: 235 N Bear Lake Blvd, Garden City, UT 84028

Phone: (435) 770-2645


About This Location

Located on the South end of Garden City and just minutes away from Raspberry Square and the beaches of Bear Lake. 

Location Features

  • Short lines

  • Great for families

  • Top-rated restaurant

  • Outdoor dining

Caribbean Custard Reviews:

Family lives in Garden city and we always visit during the summer and this is such a wonderful gem! You can try the flavors of Italian ice and gelato (didn't try one we didn't love!!!) and it's a great quality product! Perfect for after spending the day at the beach! Come by and support this great addition to Garden City.

  - Yelp

We spent a week in Bear Lake and found ourselves here almost every night. AMAZING PRODUCT AND CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!! Can’t say enough good things about this place. Do yourself a favor and try it. You won’t be disappointed.

  - Google 

Stop everything you’re doing and come here for a famous raspberry custard shake. Any other bear lake raspberry shake doesn’t compare.

  - Google 

Connect with Caribbean Custard & Italian Ice

  • Caribbean Custard and Italian Ice Yelp Page
  • Caribbean Custard - Bear Lake Ice Cream Facebook page
  • Caribbean Custard & Italian Ice Instagram Page
  • Caribbean Custard Google Reviews
bottom of page